Carlton Milo Higbie IV, better known as Carl Higbie, is a figure who sparks strong reactions wherever his name comes up. Supporters admire his straightforward, no-nonsense style and his unapologetic conservative views. Critics, on the other hand, point to his controversial remarks and the uproar that often follows them. No matter which side you’re on, Higbie’s journey—from military service to politics and media—is an intriguing one worth exploring.
Early Life and Military Service
Carl Higbie was born on April 23, 1983, in Greenwich, Connecticut. He attended Greenwich High School and later enrolled at Sacred Heart University before ultimately leaving college to enlist in the United States Navy. This decision set the stage for the career that would define his public life.
Enlisting in 2005, Higbie worked his way into one of the military’s most elite groups: the Navy SEALs. He served two tours during Operation Iraqi Freedom, seeing firsthand the intensity of modern combat. His time in the SEALs was marked by the discipline, resilience, and high stakes that come with such a demanding role.
During his service he achieved the rank of Petty Officer First Class, a testament to his dedication and competence. Like many veterans, he faced challenges when returning to civilian life, and these experiences would later influence his political and media voice. He eventually chronicled these years in two books: Battle on the Home Front: A Navy SEAL’s Mission to Save the American Dream and Enemies, Foreign and Domestic: A SEAL’s Story, both of which blend personal stories with reflections on the country’s political climate.
Political Ambitions and Public Life
After leaving the Navy ,Carl Higbie set his sights on politics. In 2014, he ran for a seat in the U.S. House of Representatives representing Connecticut’s 4th Congressional District as a Republican candidate. His platform combined traditional conservative social values—such as opposition to abortion and same-sex marriage—with calls for smaller government, lower taxes, and balanced budgets.
Despite the enthusiasm he brought to the race, Carl Higbie faced an uphill battle. Fundraising and name recognition were significant challenges, and ultimately he lost the Republican primary to another candidate. Still, the campaign gave him valuable experience and introduced him to the national political scene.
Following his run for office, Higbie became more involved in political activism and media. He worked with Great America PAC, a political action committee that supported Donald Trump, and began appearing on major news outlets to share his views on policy and national issues. These early appearances laid the groundwork for his later career as a media commentator.
Media Career and the Rise of Carl Higbie Frontline
Carl Higbie’s transition from political candidate to media personality came naturally. His military background and ability to speak plainly made him a frequent guest on cable news programs such as Fox News and CNN, where he debated topics like immigration, foreign policy, and national security.
By 2023, Higbie had his own show on Newsmax titled Carl Higbie Frontline. The program features daily discussions on government policies, media accountability, and issues of personal freedom. Carl Higbie uses the platform to highlight what he sees as government overreach and to champion conservative principles.
His on-air style is direct, often confrontational, and unapologetically patriotic. For many viewers, this is precisely what sets him apart in a crowded media environment. They value his willingness to challenge both political opponents and the mainstream press. However, that same boldness also attracts criticism from those who see his approach as unnecessarily combative or divisive.
Controversies and Public Backlash
With a career built on strong opinions, it’s no surprise that Carl Higbie has faced controversy. Over the years, several of his past remarks—made on radio programs and in interviews—have drawn sharp criticism.
One of the most high-profile incidents occurred in 2017 when Carl Higbie was appointed Chief of External Affairs for the Corporation for National and Community Service, the federal agency that oversees programs such as AmeriCorps. Soon after, recordings of previous statements surfaced in which he used inflammatory language about immigrants, minorities, and even veterans with PTSD. The backlash was swift, and Higbie resigned from the position.
Another instance that generated headlines involved his comments suggesting that a national registry for Muslim Americans could be justified, referencing a controversial World War II Supreme Court case. Civil rights groups and many political leaders condemned the statement as an attack on religious freedom. While Higbie later expressed regret and clarified some of his remarks, the incidents continue to shape public perception of him.
Impact and Role in Today’s Political Landscape
Despite the controversies, Carl Higbie remains an influential voice in conservative media. He represents a segment of the American right that is skeptical of government power and frustrated with what it sees as liberal bias in mainstream news. His military service gives him credibility among audiences that value national security and personal sacrifice, and his blunt style resonates with viewers who prefer unfiltered commentary.
Higbie’s positions are typically hard-line on issues like immigration and border control. He often argues for limited government, strong national defense, and the protection of traditional values. These stances make him a favorite among certain conservative audiences who feel that mainstream Republicans have grown too cautious or compromising.
Through Carl Higbie Frontline, he continues to influence the conversation on topics ranging from free speech to government accountability. His show allows him not only to react to breaking news but also to shape the narrative for a loyal base of viewers.
Strengths, Weaknesses, and What Lies Ahead
Strengths
One of Higbie’s greatest strengths is his authenticity. His years as a Navy SEAL give weight to his opinions on national security and patriotism, making him more than just another television pundit. He has also carved out a distinct niche with an audience that appreciates his blunt, “say it like it is” delivery.
Another strength is his growing media platform. A regular primetime show provides stability and reach, ensuring that his voice remains a part of the national conversation. For someone seeking influence without holding elected office, that’s a powerful asset.
Weaknesses
Higbie’s biggest weakness is also a by-product of his strength: his outspokenness. While it wins him fans among those who crave plain talk, it also risks alienating moderate audiences and can lead to damaging controversies. His past remarks have followed him for years and continue to spark debate.
His polarizing style can also deepen political divisions. For those seeking more nuanced or bipartisan discussions, Higbie’s approach may feel too confrontational, limiting his ability to reach across the aisle.
Looking Forward
As Higbie’s media presence grows, the key question is whether he will remain primarily a media figure or make another attempt at elected office. His future influence will depend on how well he manages his public image and whether he can avoid the kind of controversies that have forced past resignations. He will also need to navigate the increasingly competitive landscape of conservative media, where new voices emerge constantly.
Conclusion
Carl Higbie’s story is a modern example of how military service, political ambition, and media savvy can combine to create a powerful public persona. From Navy SEAL to congressional candidate to television host, he has built a career that reflects both the opportunities and the tensions of today’s political culture.
Loved by some and criticized by others, Higbie remains a significant voice in the conservative movement. Whether he continues to grow as a media figure or steps back into the political arena, his journey captures the intersection of patriotism, controversy, and the ever-evolving relationship between politics and the press.
